50 Halloween Would You Rather Questions

This list of 50 Halloween “Would You Rather” questions is designed to bring out the chills, thrills, and laughs as you and your friends and family choose between tricky dilemmas and spine-tingling scenarios. These questions will have you debating and laughing long into the witching hour. Best of all, these “Would You Rather” Halloween questions are family-friendly, making them perfect for any age group!

I’ve also created a free printable Halloween “Would You Rather” game that you can grab as well!

Halloween “Would You Rather” Questions

These Would you rather questions challenge everyone to choose between two spooky options, leading to plenty of interesting conversations and laughs. I’ve put together a list of 50 Halloween-themed “Would You Rather” questions that will keep you going for quite a while!

You might also like to check out my Thanksgiving and Christmas “Would You Rather” questions too, since the festive season comes quick after Halloween!

Ideas for Using These “Would You Rather” Questions

“Would You Rather” is a versatile game that can be adapted to fit any type of gathering or social situation. Here are some creative ideas to ensure your game is fun, engaging, and memorable:

• Halloween Dinner Table Fun: Introduce “Would You Rather” as a fun activity during your Halloween night meal. Pass around the list of questions or simply take turns asking questions at random.
• Halloween Party Icebreaker: Use “Would You Rather” questions as an icebreaker at your Halloween party to get people talking and laughing, especially if some guests are meeting for the first time or need a little extra encouragement to mingle.
• Family Game Night: Make “Would You Rather” a part of your family game night in between more traditional games.
• While Out Trick Or Treating: During your trick-or-treating, ask “Would You Rather” questions from this list to one another as you move between houses.
• Make It Active: Instead of having participants respond to each question, have them move to the left or right to suit their answers. This is a great active break for kids in the classroom but it works for any age group and makes the game more interactive!

Conversation starters for families can be helpful to get kids talking. Try these conversation starters for kids, teens, and couples, conversation starters for family dinner & Would You Rather questions for kids to get everyone talking!

Now, onto the Halloween would you rather questions!

Would You Rather Halloween Edition

Here’s a list of 50 Halloween-themed “Would You Rather” questions to spice up your spooky celebrations:

1. Would you rather be a vampire or a werewolf?
2. Would you rather have a pumpkin patch in your backyard or a haunted shed?
3. Would you rather attend a Halloween party or go trick-or-treating?
4. Would you rather dress up as a witch or a ghost?
5. Would you rather have to eat candy corn for a week or only have pumpkin pie for a week?
6. Would you rather watch a classic horror movie or a family Halloween film?
7. Would you rather encounter a friendly ghost or a mischievous spirit?
8. Would you rather have a black cat or an owl as a pet?
9. Would you rather live in a haunted mansion or a creepy castle?
10. Would you rather go to a costume party or a spooky-themed escape room?
11. Would you rather have a vampire’s immortality or a werewolf’s strength?
12. Would you rather visit a haunted house or a haunted graveyard?
13. Would you rather eat a bowl of eyeball soup or drink a cup of witches’ brew?
14. Would you rather be a character in a slasher film or a supernatural thriller?
15. Would you rather have glowing pumpkin decorations or a creepy graveyard?
16. Would you rather have to walk through a spooky forest or a haunted corn maze?
17. Would you rather have a costume that’s scary or one that’s hilarious?
18. Would you rather have a never-ending supply of Halloween candy or a lifetime of free costumes?
19. Would you rather be chased by zombies or abducted by aliens?
20. Would you rather have a zombie butler or a witch as a personal chef?
21. Would you rather explore an abandoned asylum or a spooky old church?
22. Would you rather attend a Halloween parade or a Halloween carnival?
23. Would you rather have a spell cast on you or be bitten by a werewolf?
24. Would you rather have a Halloween-themed song playlist or a collection of classic horror novels?
25. Would you rather be able to talk to ghosts or see into the future?
26. Would you rather bob for apples or carve a pumpkin?
27. Would you rather be trapped in a room with clowns or with spiders?
28. Would you rather have a Halloween-themed wedding or a Halloween-themed birthday party?
29. Would you rather dress up as a unicorn or as a fairy?
30. Would you rather play a Halloween-themed board game or a Halloween-themed video game?
31. Would you rather fly on a broomstick or use a magic wand?
32. Would you rather have a house that’s always decorated for Halloween or one that’s always decorated for Christmas?
33. Would you rather have to spend the night in a creepy hotel or in a spooky cemetery?
34. Would you rather find a hidden treasure in a haunted house or solve a mystery in a deserted town?
35. Would you rather have a jack-o-lantern head or eight spider legs?
36. Would you rather get a terrifying scare from a haunted attraction or a silly surprise from a prank?
37. Would you rather eat spooky foods or play scary games?
38. Would you rather have a magical potion or a magic mirror?
39. Would you rather be bitten by a werewolf or bitten by a vampire?
40. Would you rather have an ugly witch’s nose or have green skin?
41. Would you rather go on a ghost tour or go on a hayride?
42. Would you rather sleep in a coffin or sleep upside down?
43. Would you rather be a mad scientist or a monster hunter?
44. Would you rather be friends with a demon or a cyclops?
45. Would you rather have a pumpkin that turns into a carriage or one that grants wishes?
46. Would you rather eat nothing but candy for a week or eat no candy for a week?
47. Would you rather be invisible or be able to fly?
48. Would you rather do a Halloween escape room or a Halloween scavenger hunt?
49. Would you rather read a scary book or watch a scary film?
50. Would you rather have a pet toad or a pet spider?